The Crisis in the Church

The Church cannot fail, but her members can. These teachings address the present crisis with clarity and provide principles for remaining faithful in times of confusion and trial.

  • The Confusion
    Scandals and failures within the Church are taken as proof that the Church herself has failed.

    The Truth
    The Church, as the Body of Christ, cannot fail; however, her members—including clergy—can and do sin.

    Why It Matters
    Failing to distinguish between the Church and her members leads to loss of faith and scandal.

    Authority

    • Matthew 16:18

    • Catechism of the Council of Trent (Part I — The Creed)

    • First Vatican Council (Pastor Aeternus)

    • CCC 827

    • CCC 869

  • The Confusion
    Some deny that confusion exists, while others believe it invalidates the Church’s authority.

    The Truth
    Periods of confusion and trial can occur within the Church without altering her divine constitution or teaching.

    Why It Matters
    Recognizing this prevents both blind denial and despair, allowing the faithful to remain steady.

    Authority

    • Matthew 24:4–5

    • Catechism of the Council of Trent (Part I — The Creed)

    • CCC 675-677

  • The Confusion
    Obedience is sometimes understood as requiring unquestioning submission in all circumstances.

    The Truth
    Obedience is a virtue ordered to God and cannot require assent to error or participation in sin.

    Why It Matters
    Misunderstood obedience can lead souls into error, while rightly understood obedience preserves fidelity to the Faith.

    Authority

    • Acts 5:29

    • Catechism of the Council of Trent (Part I — The Creed)

    • CCC 2242

← Back to Main Topics
Proceed to Live the Faith →